SEASON OF JUSTICE SUPPORTS IDENTIFICATION OF SUSPECT IN 1988 MURDER OF CAROLINE BOLEN
ZIONSVILLE, Indiana – Nearly four decades after the brutal sexual assault and murder of 26-year-old Caroline Bolen, law enforcement has identified the individual responsible through advanced DNA testing and forensic genetic genealogy, supported by funding from Season of Justice.
On July 28, 1988, Caroline Bolen was attacked in her home in Silsbee, Texas. She was sexually assaulted and murdered by asphyxiation. Her 6-year-old son was present in the home and left alone with her body following the crime. Despite extensive investigative efforts at the time, no suspect was identified, and the case remained unsolved for decades.
In 2019, Investigator Justin Holt of the Silsbee Police Department reopened the case, working in collaboration with the Texas Rangers, including Ranger Brandon Bess. This renewed effort led to a re-examination of evidence and a commitment to applying modern forensic techniques.
In 2022, a DNA profile was successfully developed from evidence, including material recovered from under the victim’s fingernails. While no match was found in CODIS, investigators pursued advanced forensic genetic genealogy in partnership with Othram Inc.. That work was made possible through a grant awarded by Season of Justice, which funded the initial SNP analysis and genealogical research. A follow-up grant in 2024 supported confirmatory DNA testing.
Through these efforts, investigators identified Allen Wayne Mosely as the perpetrator. Mosely was 27 years old at the time of the murder and lived near the victim. He was on court-ordered supervision for a prior rape involving a minor at the time of the offense.
Investigators believe Mosely arrived at Bolen’s home in the early morning hours, and that she may have believed he was her boyfriend when she opened the door. The encounter escalated into a forced assault and ultimately her murder. A witness reported seeing a man matching Mosely’s description leaving the area, and evidence indicates he removed his vehicle shortly after the crime. He later relocated to Oklahoma.
Mosely died in 2006 from a self-inflicted gunshot wound following a domestic dispute. Due to his death, prosecution is not possible. However, additional investigation has linked him to multiple other sexual assault allegations involving minors.
“This case represents both the tragedy of a life taken far too soon and the enduring commitment of law enforcement to seek answers,” said Angela Mew, Executive Director of Season of Justice. “We are honored to support agencies like the Silsbee Police Department and the Texas Rangers in their pursuit of truth and accountability. While we cannot undo the harm, we can help bring clarity and a measure of closure to families who have waited far too long.”
The successful identification of the suspect was made possible through the collaborative efforts of the Silsbee Police Department, Texas Rangers, Texas Department of Public Safety Crime Laboratory, Othram Inc., and Season of Justice.
Although the suspect will not face prosecution, the resolution of this case provides long-awaited answers to Caroline Bolen’s family and ensures that her story is not forgotten.
Be a part of our next SOJ Solve – Learn how here.